The dining room was in good shape - it just needed a paint job.
Two features worth keeping were the chair rail and the exposed brick, which turned out to be fake, which only added to the charm.
Replaced the chandelier with a mid-century style fixture from CB2.
Faux-Saarinen table, chairs and sideboard also from CB2
Rug is a modern dhurrie from Crate and Barrel
Metal blinds are Hunter-Douglas
60s mirror was something I found on Etsy and actually had to glue together myself (they couldn't figure out how to ship it assembled without it breaking, but it was cheap enough not to matter) And again, found that one by googling "60s round mirrors for walls" or something in that vein.
Drapes are Tantsu from Marimekko and are the white-on-white version of the living room drapes
Paint: Benjamin Moore Icing on the Cake (light blue) and West Coast (dark blue)